I'm so excited to offer you a giveaway of the anthology Beyond
Belief, The Secret Lives of Women in Extreme Religions. This is also
your opportunity to join Cami and Susan for a discussion on: "Why
Women Stay in Religious Communities."
Thank you, WOW Women on Writing, for inviting me to host Cami and Susan today.
Beyond Belief addresses what happens when women of extreme religions decide to walk
away. Editors Cami Ostman (a de-converted fundamentalist born-again Christian)and Susan Tive (a former Orthodox Jew) have compiled a collection of
powerful personal stories written by women of varying ages, races, and
religious backgrounds who share one commonality: they’ve all experienced and
rejected extreme religions.
Covering a wide range of religious communities—including Evangelical, Catholic,
Jewish, Mormon, Muslim, Calvinist, Moonie, and Jehovah’s Witness—and containing
contributions from authors like Julia Scheeres (Jesus Land), the stories in Beyond Belief reveal how these women became involved, what their lives were like, and
why they came to the decision to eventually abandon their faiths. The authors
shed a bright light on the rigid expectations and misogyny so often built into
religious orthodoxy, yet they also explain the lure—why so many women are
attracted to these lifestyles, what they find that’s beautiful about living a
religious life, and why leaving can be not only very difficult but also
bittersweet.
Please welcome Cami and Susan in conversation.
Why Women Stay in Religious Communities
Cami: We often get asked why women stay in religions which
restrict their movements in the world or limit their freedoms. As you might
imagine, Susan and I have talked a great deal about this; it was one of our
primary guiding questions as we sorted through submissions for Beyond Belief. Why would a smart
woman (perhaps even a well-educated woman) stay in a religion that restricted
her actions and opportunities or, as in some religions, downright blamed her—by
virtue of being Eve's sister—for sin existing in the world? Let me first speak
for myself.
I adopted my faith as a teenager, at a time when I needed
guidance and structure. By the time I was an adult ready to guide my own life,
my whole worldview was informed by my theology and my entire sense of community
was built around my church. Although fear of outsiders wasn't as strong in my
situation as it was for some of the other women who contributed to Beyond Belief, my community nevertheless
had an "us and them" attitude that made me feel I was in a very special,
very chosen group. Far from this feeding my ego, it gave me an
overwhelming sense of responsibility toward the rest of the world—to evangelize
them. And the only people who understood that responsibility were those who
shared my faith.
Though every woman who stays in a restrictive religion has
her own story, one of the commonalities is that tight knit religious
communities provide a sense of safety and of being understood—until you step
outside of their expectations.
What would you add from your experience, Susan?
Susan: Traditional religions offer women great support and
encouragement especially in so far as they uphold the roles of wives and
mothers. In my faith community, Orthodox Judaism, I felt, for the first time, valued
as a stay at home mom. My role was honored and reinforced not just with passing
lip service but with actual laws and rituals that celebrated the importance of
family and home. Before I joined I had searched for but hadn’t found that kind
of structure in the secular world and I knew if I went back out there I would
lose a way of life that had helped me find meaning in my role as a woman and a
mother. It’s never easy to give up structure, identity and security even if you
have it because you are trading your rights and freedoms for it.
In my case, as with some of our other writers, I stayed
because of the real threat that I might lose my children if I left. It took me
many years to finally gather the strength I needed to make the break.
As many of our writers have noted leaving can be
disorienting and downright scary. Women who leave must walk away from a way of
life in which they have put their whole hearts. Their own identity, sense of
meaning, purpose and place in the world is bound up in their faith. Add to that
the fear of the how to function in the outside world as many religious
communities tend to isolate women and you can see why leaving is such a huge
and heroic decision to make.
Cami: Exactly, in order to leave, one needs to have
resources elsewhere. The only thing I would add to this is that, much as with
an abusive marriage, the sweet times can be very sweet. Sometimes there can
even be long periods when the feelings of being protected and accepted are at
least as intense as the sense that one is slowly dying of spiritual/psychological/personal
starvation.
We obviously don't have all the answers, but we are glad to
have had the chance to explore the question and we'd welcome hearing from
readers. What have you stayed in too long (maybe it was a relationship or a job
instead of a faith community) that asked you to be less than who you knew you
could be? Why did you stay? What helped you decide to leave?
Susan: One thing that has
surprised me about our writers is that very few of them have become bitter or anti-religious by their experience. The majority while no longer religious are
still very considerate of the faiths they left behind and will openly admit to
what they miss about their religious life and what they still carry with them.
One of the goals for Beyond Belief
was that by giving women the opportunity to tell their stories we could create
a dialogue that would be healing and helpful for both writers and readers. It’s
gratifying to see that the anthology has achieved that goal.
****
Thank you so much, Cami and Susan. Even though I'm not from an extreme religious background, I find this a fascinating subject - one that I've been introduced to many times in the last few years. I admire the bravery of these women to break away and still remain whole and productive.
Please leave a comment here at Choices to be in the running for a free copy of Beyond Belief. The winner will be picked at random next Wednesday, October 2, 2013.
Author Bios:
Cami Ostman is an author, editor,
life coach and a licensed marriage and family therapist with publications in
her field. She blogs at 7marathons7continents.com and on
the psychologytoday.com blogger team. She
has appeared in several publications, including O, The Oprah Magazine, Fitness
Magazine, Adventures Northwest, the Mudgee Guardian in Australia, and La Prensa
in Chile. Cami is a runner and a dog lover who lives in Bellingham, Washington.
As a writer, editor and researcher
Susan Tive has worked on a variety of academic articles exploring psychology,
feminism and religion. Susan’s interest in these subjects led her to become an
editor for several non-fiction titles including Faith and Feminism and Rachel’s
Bag. Her new anthology Beyond Belief: The Secret Lives of Women in Extreme
Religions was published in April 2013 by Seal Press.
Find out more about these ladies by visiting them online:
Book Facebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Beyond-Belief-The-Secret-Lives-of-Women-in-Extreme-Religions/341371765891595
Cami's Twitter: https://twitter.com/camiostman
Book Information:
Paperback: 328 PagesPublisher: Seal Press (April 2, 2013)ISBN-10: 1580054420Twitter hashtag: #SLWExtreme
Beyond Belief: The Secret Lives of Women in Extreme Religions is available as a print and ebook at Amazon.
