I’m so
honored to have Sharon Melton Lippincott as my first guest. We met a few months
ago when we both participated on a Google+ hangout, and we have found a mutual
connection regarding memoir and lifestory writing ever since. Sharon wrote a
wonderful review of my memoir, Leaving
the Hall Light On for the Story
Circle Book Reviews, which I’m sure helped catapult it to the Story Circle
Editors’ book pick for November. Thank you so much, Sharon, for being here
today. And that you chose to write about reading my book is a huge bonus!
A Writer’s Read on
Leaving the Hall Light On
by Sharon Melton
Lippincott
About
five years ago I responded to a challenge and began posting reviews of books on
Amazon and other sites, unaware that doing so would change the way I read and
ultimately the way I write. Over sixty reviews later, I can honestly say that
the enjoyment and value I get from reading has at least tripled.
This enhanced
reading mode led me to notice many fascinating aspects of Madeline Sharples’
memoir, Leaving the Hall Light On.
Let me share a few with you that may also enhance your reading of the book:
The first
chapter reminds me of leaves swirling in a whirlwind before they come to rest, or
puzzle pieces awaiting assembly. I was instantly swept into the nightmarish
scene that forms the heart, the core, of this book. It appears that life
previous to this scene spirals inward toward the horror that began on this day.
Everything after spirals out beyond, but all of Madeline's subsequent life is
anchored to this moment.
The
shocking start instantly introduces Paul, the focus of the book, then she jumps
directly into the book’s present. From there she circles back to the time of
Paul’s birth, essentially laying out a map of the story, bit by bit. She
summarizes her thoughts, explains the title, and summarizes the situation with
a story. I was energized at the conclusion of the final poem, and eager to
learn more.
This is a
chapter of fragments, pieces of a puzzle laid out to show us the range of the
story. The rest of the book fits them together. Emotion swirls as rapidly as
events, mixing joy, guilt, rage and love with abandon. I experience the added
richness the photo and poems lend to the pulsing narrative, bluntly introducing
truths and paving the way for further discussion.
Moving
through subsequent chapters I discover that this book has an unusual structure:
each chapter has a theme that could stand on its own. Each chapter is a spoke,
connecting the core of the story with the larger picture. I notice how she
gradually develops Paul as a character, showing a bit of him here, a bit there;
ultimately I feel as if I also knew him, achieving one of her primary purposes.
I notice
that this structure calls for some material to be told two or three times,
sometimes from alternate perspectives, sometimes seeming a bit repetitive. I
pay close attention to the way she writes about her initial state of denial,
virtually gutting her psyche and laying it out for our inspection. What
courage, I think. She not only lived through this once, she lived through it
again in the writing.
I admire
the way she uses snippets of her husband’s journals to allow him to give his
own perspective, which cleverly works around the memoirist’s dilemma of not
being able to put words in someone else’s mouth. She also uses input from her
son Ben to circumvent traditional limitations and enrich her story.
Rather
than continue, I leave the rest of the book for you to explore, hopefully with
more insight as you think about reviewing it. Perhaps you can tell that reading
has acquired a third dimension, introducing depth and meaning I’d previously sensed
only vaguely, if at all. You can read the review I ultimately wrote here.
Sharon
bio:
"You
make me think!" When she hears this line, Sharon Lippincott, author of The
Heart and Craft of Lifestory Writing, knows she's been successful. Her
insightful questions and observations have challenged people in many areas for
decades. Today they are primarily aimed at students in her lifestory and
creative writing classes along with readers of her blog, forum posts, book
reviews, and other publications. Sharon serves on the Advisory Board of the
National Association of Memoir Writers, cohosts the lively Life Writers Forum
on YahooGroups, and advises the Allegheny County Library Association on their
project to implement lifestory writing groups in county libraries. She
frequently appears as a panelist on the Indie Authors webcast, and lives and
writes in Monroeville, PA. Sharon maintains her own blog, The Heart and Craft of Life Writing.
Sharon, This is a fascinating analysis of Madeline's stunning memoir. You have turned a book review into an art form! Having already read ( and loved)this memoir, I find I am looking at it with new eyes through your razor-sharp insights and witty spin on story structure and events. Your "third dimension" does add depth and meaning to the story. Thanks for showing us all how doing book reviews can help deepen our own reading and writing experiences.
ReplyDeleteThank you Kathy. When writing the post I forgot to urge all readers to begin reviewing books themselves. Joining the ranks of legitimate reviewers is the best way of helping combat the sock puppet, paid review mills, and carpet bombers who are making a mockery of the review process. But most of all, you'll get way more out of your reading once you begin reviewing.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Kathleen, Sharon: 'You have turned a book review into an art form.' Madeline's memoir is one of my treasures; now, so is your review of LEAVING THE HALL LIGHT ON. Touched me in the deepest of places, re-engaging me with the substance of Madeline's journey.
ReplyDeleteThank you everyone. I'm so glad Sharon's post has gotten so much attention today. I'm already thinking of planning another guest post blast.
ReplyDeleteSharon, I cannot find any way to say it, except that I wholeheartedly agree with Kathy and Dody -- "You have turned a book review into an art form." Thank goodness I had just pressed "schedule" on my review of Madeline's book coming out on my blog tomorrow, or I would have felt so inadequate to the task.
ReplyDeleteI too love Madeline's book for several reasons mentioned in my review, but you have tempted me to head back and re-read using different eyes and senses. Thank you!
I posted my first review of a book on my blog last week. I didn't do it with much intention, I just wanted to share about a book that has helped me so much. But I have to say, it was a great experience. I don't think I'll do it too often, but I will do it again. I also haven't had any guest posts or author interviews - I'm beginning to think it might be fun to do that too. Hmmm...I see several potential guests here. LOL
ReplyDeleteDear Karen, Thanks for sharing your review experience. I hope you'll do more and then get started inviting guests to your blog. It's always nice to change the perspective a bit.
ReplyDelete